| YEAR | OFFENSE | DEFENSE |
|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Kahale Burns, Bald Eagle Area Bryce Danish, Mount Union |
Rocco Serafini, Central Mountain Ashton Steele, Huntingdon |
| 2023 | Miles Brooks, Penns Valley Dominic Yanoshak, Bishop Guilfoyle |
Connor Williams, Moshannon Valley Eli Lingenfelter, Central |
| 2022 | Suds Dubler, Glendale Jacob Condo, Juniata |
Hayden Kovalick, Clearfield Parker Gregg, Central |
| 2021 | Baine Seilhammer, Glendale Gabe Brower, Juniata Valley |
Nick Domico, Clearfield Kyle Murray, Altoona |
| 2019 | Tommy Friberg, State College Quinn Zinobile, Juniata Valley |
Derek Yingling, West Branch Braedon Nevling-Ray, Tyrone |
| 2018 | Nick Steward, Curwensville Ian Border, Huntingdon |
Dylan LeCates, Brockway Mark Conrad, Bishop Guilfoyle |
| 2017 | Braden Paulinellie, DuBois Jarrett Cavalet, Hollidaysburg |
Peyton Edwards, State College Kyle Dodson, Central |
| 2016 | Justin Helsel, Central Quemone Newkirk, Curwensville |
Braydon Kylor, Mount Union Nate Lash, Clearfield |
| 2015 | Eli Mencer, Altoona John Weakland, State College |
BJ Loner,Mount Union Brad Peterson, DuBois |
| 2014 | Cameron Tobias, Penns Valley Bradi Moore, Central |
Tyler Stratton, Clearfield John Maclay, Mifflin County |
| 2013 | Von Walker, Central Mountain Brian Urban, Hollidaysburg |
Dan Fry, State College Matt Barton, Hollidaysburg |
| 2012 | Ryan Stuby, Bellwood-Antis Beau Swales, Clearfield |
Corbin Nevling-Ray, Tyrone Holden Whitehead, Central Mountain |
| 2011 | Lucas Runk, Central Tyler Lucas, Bellefonte |
DeRon Lee, Altoona Elliot Dillion, Penns Valley |
| 2010 | Jed Greslick, Curwensville James Muir, Hollidaysburg |
Kevin Grejda, Clarion Andrew Cerett, Huntingdon Nick Degol, Bellwood-Antis |
| 2009 | Jarrin Campman, Clearfield Larry Glace, Tyrone |
Andrew Gordon, DuBois Jimmy Smith, Mount Union |
| 2008 | Jay Hartman, Indian Valley Ryan Poorman, Bellefonte |
Shane Tate, Tyrone Justin Karp, Clearfield |
| 2007 | Jacob Librizzi, Bishop Guilfoyle Tyler Ross, Brookville |
Wes Plummer, Altoona Shawn Sopic, Curwensville |
| 2006 | Robbie Hanzley, DuBois Leonard Wilson, Tyrone |
Tim Smeal, West Branch Chad Saylor, Central |
| 2005 | Tanner Kelly, Clearfield Tyson Maugle, Hollidaysburg |
Ron Pollock, Philipsburg-Osceola Trey McClain, Mount Union |
| 2004 | Geoff Kozak, Huntingdon Andy Pugh, Hollidaysburg |
Scott Koch, State College Chris Gould, Central Mountain |
| 2003 | Brendan Perretta, Altoona Dave Richards, Clearfield |
Matt Davis, Hollidaysburg Jon Altemus, Clearfield |
| 2002 | Wes Krider, Central Jon Pribble, Central Mountain |
Dylan Crilly, Hollidaysburg Lance Thompson, Moshannon Valley |
| 2001 | Jesse Jones, Tyrone Philip Mann, Central Mountain |
Alex Dimoff, Mount Union Matt Harnish, Curwensville |
| 2000 | Justin Marshall, DuBois Kris Fideli, Altoona |
Jon Condo, Philipsburg-Osceola David Pisanick, Hollidaysburg |
| 1999 | Josh Tkacik, Curwensville Chad Brindle, Huntingdon |
Ben Lago, Bald Eagle Area Matt Deamer, Indian Valley |
| 1998 | Larry Johnson, State College Josh Geis, Altoona |
Matt Maggs, Bald Eagle Nittany Mathias Harmon, Central |
| 1997 | Eric Kaufman, Clearfield JJ Easter, Mount Union |
Justin Ditty, Bucktail Jonathan Seiner, Tyrone |
| 1996 | Ryan Hostler, Bellwood-Antis Tim Kail, DuBois |
Jason Evans, Huntingdon Mike Kemerer, Bald Eagle Nittany |
| 1995 | Chad Kroell, Clearfield Wes Green, Huntingdon |
Scott Latosky, Moshannon Valley Jason Showwalter, Juniata Valley |
| 1994 | Tom Snyder, Mount Union Brandon Knarr, Lock Haven |
Dave Berkhimer, Claysburg-Kimmel Joe Frank, Philipsburg-Osceola |
| 1993 | Ferdie Vaughn, Mount Union Jeff Nixon, State College |
Norm Huddy, Punxsutawney Shanon Manning, Penns Valley |
| 1992 | Don Gentzyl, Bucktail Matt Kemmerer, Punxsutawney Brett Rankin, Punxsutawney |
Brian Carper, Penns Valley Karl Montanaro, Bellwood-Antis |
| 1991 | Chris McCartney, Bellwood-Antis Wade Kurzinger, Bald Eagle Area |
Eric Benatsky, Purchase Line Bill Stringfellow, Bald Eagle Nittany |
| 1990 | Bruce Graham, Clearfield Dave Wyland, Hollidaysburg |
Todd Hardy, Bellefonte Lew "Buddy" Tress, Mount Union |
| 1989 | Jim Renninger, Bald Eagle Nittany Dave Hensor, Juniata Valley |
Bob Oakes, State College Mike Koehle, Bishop Guilfoyle |
| 1988 | Matt Koehle, Bishop Guilfoyle Tim Fritz, Lock Haven |
Mike Cheslock, Altoona Brent Dunmire, Lewistown |
| 1987 | Rick Hoover, Altoona Doug Sieg, Bellefonte |
Cord Ferrari, Huntingdon Tom Bowser, State College |
| 1986 | Bill Hesketh, Kishacoquillas John Carey, Bishop Guilfoyle |
Bob Shea, Curwensville Craig Sellers, Huntingdon |
| 1985 | Joe Irwin, Bishop Guilfoyle Keith Powell, Philipsburg-Osceola |
George Zlupko, Altoona Bill Andrus, Bellefonte |
